PHD Discussions Logo

Ask, Learn and Accelerate in your PhD Research

Question Icon Post Your Answer

Question Icon

10 months ago in Interrogation Ethics By Vishal

Does torture actually work‑ the evidence on enhanced interrogation

Proponents of "enhanced interrogation" claim it produces life-saving intelligence. Is there actual empirical evidence to back this up?

All Answers (1 Answers In All)

By Daniel Answered 10 months ago

No. The Senate Select Committee on Intelligence's comprehensive review found no credible evidence that waterboarding or other EITs produced reliable, actionable intelligence not obtainable through lawful, rapport-based methods. Intelligence professionals and interrogators with field experience consistently affirm that coercion breeds falsehoods: subjects say whatever they think will stop the pain. The consensus across the empirical literature is clear: EITs are ineffective, counterproductive, and their supposed efficacy is unsupported by evidence.

Your Answer