PHD Discussions Logo

Ask, Learn and Accelerate in your PhD Research

Question Icon Post Your Answer

Question Icon

What are the responsibilities of a scholar regarding the replication of their own and others’ work?

The "replication crisis" is a big topic in my field. As an early-career researcher, what is my role? Should I spend time trying to replicate foundational studies, or ensure my own work is perfectly replicable? What are the practical steps?

All Answers (1 Answers In All)

By Trisha Answered 10 months ago

Your primary responsibility is to ensure your own work is replicable. This means pre-registering studies, sharing de-identified data and analysis code in trusted repositories (e.g., OSF, Zenodo), and documenting methods exhaustively. This is now a baseline expectation in many fields. Regarding others' work, direct replication studies are a vital scholarly service, though they are often undervalued. If you build on a prior study, include a "conceptual" or "methods-plus" replication as a preliminary step to verify the foundation. Advocate for norms that reward replication by publishing in dedicated journals (e.g., ReScience, Journal of Replication Studies) and citing them prominently. Scholarship is a collective enterprise; your duty is to strengthen its foundations, not just build new towers on sand.

Your Answer