PHD Discussions Logo

Ask, Learn and Accelerate in your PhD Research

Question Icon Post Your Answer

Question Icon

What defines "academic scholarship" in today’s digital age beyond traditional journal publications?

My tenure file emphasizes "scholarly impact," but my work includes blogs, data sets, and software. Are these considered legitimate scholarship, or do I still need to focus only on peer-reviewed articles to be taken seriously?

All Answers (1 Answers In All)

By Amol Answered 1 year ago

Scholarship is evolving beyond the PDF. Rigorous digital scholarship—curated datasets, peer-reviewed software, influential public writing, and digital exhibits—is increasingly recognized as legitimate contribution, especially when it involves peer-like review and advances knowledge. The key is documented impact and rigor. For tenure, frame these outputs within a scholarly narrative: explain the intellectual contribution, the peer feedback (even if via GitHub issues or public commentary), and the measurable impact (usage statistics, policy citations, media mentions). Pair non-traditional work with traditional publications that contextualize it. Many universities now embrace "scholarship of application and engagement." Check your institution's promotion guidelines and build a portfolio that demonstrates both innovation and substantive impact on your field and the public.

Your Answer